Movie Review: ‘Another Simple Favor’

‘Another Simple Favor’ receives 7 out of 10 stars.

Arriving globally on Prime Video on May 1st, ‘Another Simple Favor’ throws us back into the knotty dynamic of mommy vlogger-turned-crime sleuth Stephanie Smothers (Anna Kendrick) and mysterious, murderous fashion plate Emily Nelson (Blake Lively).

This sequel to the 2018 murder mystery brought to screens by director Paul Feig, looks to amp up the mystery even further, throwing in new family members and some luxurious Italian island locations.

Related Article: Paul Feig Talks ‘Jackpot!’ and Working with Awkwafina and John Cena

Will ‘Another Simple Favor’ ask too much of you?

Blake Lively stars as ‘Emily’ in ‘Another Simple Favor’. Credit: Lorenzo Sisti. Copyright: © 2025 Amazon Content Services LLC.

On television, there’s a common trick of sitcoms and other shows usually anchored to one place to goose things up by taking the characters on holiday. ‘The Brady Bunch’ went to Hawaii. ‘Friends’ brought us “The One in Barbados” and the usually hospital-bound ‘Scrubs’ splashed out for a destination wedding in the Bahamas.

‘Another Simple Favor’ tries a similar trick, albeit in movie form (though it is premiering on Prime Video), moving its murder mystery machinations to the picturesque isle of Capri in Italy. But is it enough to elevate everything? That’s a more complicated question, one whose answer is both yes and no.

Script and Direction

Paul Feig attends the Amazon MGM Studios ‘Another Simple Favor’ New York Special Screening on Sunday, April 27, 2025 at Jazz at Lincoln Center, New York City. Photo: Prime Video.

The sequel boasts the writing talents of Jessica Sharzer (who adapted ‘A Simple Favor’ from the novel by Darcey Bell and has written the likes of ‘Nerve,’ and episodes of ‘American Horror Story’) with Laeta Kalogridis –– more known for the dramatic ‘Shutter Island’ and ‘Alita: Battle Angel’ –– taking a pass.

Together, they have concocted something that feels as though it has a similar energy to the original movie, while looking to heighten things to an even more absurd degree. Which is saying something, given that the 2018 effort had more turns than a corkscrew.

‘A Simple Favor’ effectively blended its mystery and comedy tones together, and while the follow-up attempts the same trick with some new complications, it mostly manages it, while sometimes tipping too far into ridiculousness.

(L to R) Stephanie (Anna Kendrick), Dante (Michele Morrone), Emily (Blake LIvely), and Vicky (Alex Newell) in ‘Another Simple Favor’. Credit: Lorenzo Sisti. Copyright: © 2025 Amazon Content Services LLC.

Still, there are the requisite laughs to be found here, and enough twists to keep you guessing. Once the new main mystery is revealed, it does rather start to deflate, and there is some egregious sequel baiting towards the end.

Feig, returning as director, proves he can adeptly hop between genres, and being let loose in the beautiful island of Capri certainly allows him to up the visual interest of the movie. He also capably manages the new cast recruits while keeping the focus squarely where it should be: the winning, sometimes overly catty dynamic between Kendrick’s Stephanie and Lively’s Emily.

Cast and Performances

(L to R) Stephanie (Anna Kendrick) and Emily (Blake LIvely) in ‘Another Simple Favor’. Credit: Lorenzo Sisti. Copyright: © 2025 Amazon Content Services LLC.

Lively might be the superstar here, but it’s Anna Kendrick who really keeps the movie grounded and funny. As Stephanie, who is awkwardly trying to enjoy her newfound fame following the events of the original film (and capitalize on them by writing a book about the case), Kendrick remains the comic powerhouse of the film, whether she’s effectively narrating the movie through her video channel or trading barbs with Lively’s Emily (or, er, Hope, as she should really be called.)

As for Lively, she’s back in full-on comic-inflected femme fatale mode, as she struts around in outrageous clothing and gets passive-aggressive with Kendrick’s character. She once more makes an impact, whether she’s plotting her next move or proving more of a friend to Stephanie than she might have suspected.

There’s also a healthy vein of vulnerability in both the leads, which makes the characters as relatable in the past, even as the screwball murder mystery is dialed up into ever more frenzied levels of complexity.

Around them, a collection of returning and new performers add extra layers to the story.

Henry Golding stars as ‘Sean’ in ‘Another Simple Favor’. Credit: Lorenzo Sisti. Copyright: © 2025 Amazon Content Services LLC.

Henry Golding is able to let loose more as Sean, Emily’s ex-husband (who had a dalliance with Stephanie in the original), and here is a drunken, sarcastic mess, throwing endless shade at his ex.

Of the newcomers, the highlights are Alex Newell, who steals moments and scenes as Stephanie’s enthusiastic assistant/book tour manager Vicky and Elena Sofia Ricci as Portia Versano, the powerful, calculating mother of Emily’s new fiancé Dante (Michele Morrone), neither of whom show up on google searches, but are clearly very rich and powerful –– it won’t take you long to guess why.

Less present, but still entertaining are Detective Summervile (Bashir Salahuddin, returning from the original) and FBI agent Irene Walker (Taylor Ortega), who help drive the plot while not forgetting to bring the laughs.

The really nutritious additions to the cast are Allison Janney and Elizabeth Perkins, who consume whole sections of scenery playing Emily’s grasping aunt and drunken mother.

Final Thoughts

(L to R) Emily (Blake LIvely), Dante (Michele Morrone), Vicky (Alex Newell) and Stephanie (Anna Kendrick) in ‘Another Simple Favor’. Credit: Lorenzo Sisti. Copyright: © 2025 Amazon Content Services LLC.

‘A Simple Favor’ sometimes coasted on the power of its stars and some fun plot turns, and ‘Another Simple Favor’ falls into a similar trap.

Still, the idyllic countryside helps it feel different enough, and though it can’t quite keep the momentum up towards the end, watching it is not too much of an ask.

What’s the plot of ‘Another Simple Favor’?

Stephanie Smothers (Anna Kendrick) and Emily Nelson (Blake Lively) reunite on the beautiful island of Capri, Italy, for Emily’s extravagant wedding to a rich Italian businessman.

Along with the glamorous guests, expect murder and betrayal to RSVP for a wedding with more twists and turns than the road from the Marina Grande to the Capri town square.

Who stars in ‘Another Simple Favor’?

• Anna Kendrick as Stephanie Smothers
• Blake Lively as Emily Nelson
• Henry Golding as Sean Townsend
• Andrew Rannells as Darren
• Bashir Salahuddin as Detective Summerville
• Elizabeth Perkins as Margaret McLinden
• Michele Morrone as Dante Versano
• Elena Sofia Ricci as Portia Versano
• Alex Newell as Vicky
• Allison Janney as Aunt Linda McLinden
• Joshua Satine as Miles Smothers
• Ian Ho as Nicholas “Nicky” Townsend-Nelson
• Kelly McCormack as Stacy
• Taylor Ortega as Agent Irene Walker
• Lorenzo de Moor as Matteo Bartolo
• Aparna Nancherla as Sona

‘Another Simple Favor’ premieres on Prime Video May 1st. Photo: Amazon.

List of Paul Feig Movies and TV Shows:

Buy Paul Feig Movies on Amazon